When should you hire a marketing agency? — Peaceful Media
← Blog

When should you hire a marketing agency? A test for personal brand businesses

The signs it's time for a coach, author, speaker or expert to hand off marketing: the revenue points where it makes sense, the work only you can do, and how to weigh what doing it all yourself really costs.

Against a night sky, a card titled 'Only you, or someone else?' with three rows: only you, for keynotes, books, being on camera and big conversations; someone else can, for scripts, editing, emails, ads and analytics; and when to hire, starting lean at $100,000 to $150,000 and leaning in from $250,000.

The short answerHire a marketing agency when a real share of your week goes to work someone else could do, and it's taking time from the work only you can do. For coaches, authors, speakers and other personal brand businesses aiming for $500,000 to $1 million a year or more, start considering a lean marketing team at $100,000 to $150,000 in revenue, and lean in heavily from $250,000. If you're happy where you are, a freelancer for specific jobs is enough. The test is simple: list your marketing tasks and mark each one 'only me' (keynotes, books, being on camera, high-stakes client and partner conversations) or 'someone else can' (scripting, editing, posting, newsletters, CRM automations, running ads, analytics). If the second list is eating hours you could spend on the first, the opportunity cost is already higher than an agency's fee.

We’re a marketing agency, so we have an obvious interest in this question. The honest answer is that hiring one too early wastes money, and hiring one too late costs more than you’d think. Here’s how to tell which side of that line you’re on.

The short answer

Hire help when a real share of your week goes to work someone else could do, and it’s taking time from the work only you can do.

When depends on what you want. For the businesses we work with, mostly personal brands like coaches, authors, speakers and teachers:

RevenueIf your goal is $500,000 to $1 million or more
$100,000 to $150,000Start considering a lean marketing team
$250,000 and upLean in heavily with a full marketing team

Somewhere past $250,000, most founders notice that half their day goes to tasks that don’t need them.

If you don’t want to grow past where you are, that’s a perfectly good choice. Hire a freelancer for this job or that one and keep your business the size you like it.

Matching the team to your ambition

The case for a full team is strongest when you want to move beyond one-to-one coaching and consulting: to be a recognized speaker on the circuit, a YouTube personality, a regular guest on podcasts and shows, with an audience and email list big enough to command premium speaking, consulting and coaching fees. That kind of visibility is built by a team that has done it before, while you spend your time on the stage and the page.

Two kinds of work

Sort everything you do for your marketing into two lists.

Only you can do thisSomeone else can do this
Being on camera and the face of your programContent strategy, scripts and titles
Keynotes, workshops and teachingEditing, thumbnails, posting and SEO
Writing your booksManaging comments and community
High-stakes conversations with clients and partnersWriting newsletters and building email automations
The ideas and the point of viewRunning ads and digging through analytics

The left column makes you money and nobody can take it over. The right column needs doing well, but it doesn’t need you.

Signs it’s time

  • You’re editing your own videos, or putting off recording because the rest of the process takes so long
  • You spend evenings writing newsletters or wiring up CRM automations
  • You run your own ads and then lose hours in analytics trying to work out what’s working
  • You’re taking courses to learn marketing skills you’ll never use as well as a specialist
  • Speaking invitations, book chapters or partner conversations are waiting because marketing comes first

Learning how marketing works is useful. Becoming the person who does all of it usually isn’t your best job.

You’ve waited too long when you’re close to burnout, or marketing is eating into time with family and friends. If you’re running ads, posting or answering comments at night and starting to feel guilty about where your time goes, start talking to agencies. A good one takes that work off your plate and pays for itself in revenue, and you should enjoy working with them too.

Jason Miller, founder of Peaceful Media

What it costs you to keep doing it all

Put a number on it. Here’s a worked example, with the numbers for illustration:

Example
Annual revenue$300,000
Hours worked a yearAbout 2,000
Value of an hour of your timeAbout $150
Hours a week on someone-else-can work15
What that costs a year (48 weeks)About $108,000

That’s the cost of the time alone, before counting what you’d earn if those hours went to keynotes, launches or clients. When that number is bigger than what a team would charge, waiting is the expensive choice. Our pricing guides show what different kinds of help cost.

What handing it off looks like: YouTube

A team can never be the face of your YouTube channel. What it can do is take away everything that makes video tedious. That means the content strategy, the scripts, the titles, the editing, the SEO, the posting and the comments.

You sit down knowing exactly what to film, why you’re filming it, and what it should do for your rankings. Then you hand the footage over. While we ran Sonia Choquette’s channel, it grew from about 15,000 to 335,000 subscribers.

What the right team makes possible

The Soil Food Web School is a good example. It already had a small internal team. Adding our strategists and specialists alongside them made launches repeatable and grew every channel:

  • We ran 17+ quarterly launches, including seven-figure-plus launches
  • The email list went from under 3,000 to more than 400,000
  • That bigger list let the school sell other programs and products throughout the year, between launches

Our team worked alongside theirs, adding the specialists it couldn’t have hired on its own.

When it’s too early

An agency won’t fix an offer that doesn’t sell yet. If you’re still deciding what to sell, who it’s for or what to charge, spend on that first. The same goes if you can’t fund both the agency and any ad spend it will need. A smaller first step, like a single project, a simple plan you run yourself, or our free Launch Planner, is the better move.

Where to go next

If you think you’re ready, our guide on choosing a marketing agency as a coach or speaker covers which kind of partner fits your stage, and how to vet a marketing agency covers the questions to ask. You can also see how we work with coaches, authors and certification programs.

FAQ

Related questions

At what revenue should a small business hire a marketing agency?

It depends on your ambition. If you want to grow a personal brand business to $500,000 or $1 million a year, start considering a lean marketing team at $100,000 to $150,000 in revenue, and lean in heavily from $250,000. If you're content where you are, a freelancer for specific jobs is enough, and that's a perfectly good choice.

What marketing work should a founder keep doing?

The work that depends on you: being on camera, giving keynotes, writing books, leading the program, and the high-stakes conversations with clients and partners. A team can't be the face of your YouTube channel, but it can make every recording session count by handling the strategy, scripts, titles, editing, posting and community.

Is it too early to hire an agency if my offer is still changing?

Usually, yes. An agency amplifies an offer that already sells. If you're still testing what to sell, who it's for, or what to charge, spend on that first. A short strategy engagement can help, but a full marketing team will mostly scale your uncertainty.

Should I hire an in-house marketer or an agency first?

For most personal brand businesses between $100,000 and $500,000, an agency or full-service team comes first, because you need several specialists (strategy, video, email, ads, analytics) and rarely enough work to keep each one busy full time. An in-house coordinator becomes worth it later, often working alongside the agency.

Which kind of partner fits your stage
How do I know if hiring an agency will pay off?

Do the math on your own time first. Take the hours a week you spend on work someone else could do, multiply by what an hour of your time is worth, and compare that to the agency's fee. Then ask the agency what it expects to change in the first six months and how it will measure it.

How to vet a marketing agency